Sources of Violence by Keith Hebden explains the motivators of violence.
Hebden brings up a theme of violence in the Old and New Testament. He
states, “… Christian witness might lead us to believe that God’s
violence is a moral and practical option”. In V for Vendetta, V believes
his acts of violence are for a good cause. V kills people, and destroys
things in the hope to gain control over the government. The government
has taken away citizen’s freedom. I think V justifies his actions for
being a moral and practical option, because it’s for a greater cause. On
the other hand, the government also probably justifies their actions
for being a moral and practical option, because they feel their actions
are the only way to save the country. Hebden also says, “The prophets,
to whom we turn for visions of justice, and mercy, are rarely any
gentler than the Judges, Kings, and Psalmists.” Like God, prophets are
seen as morally just figures. Hebden says God and prophets who are seen
as religious figures who are looked up to have committed violent acts.
The government and V are both doing violent acts for the same reason God
and the prophets did. Well at least they justify their acts and reasons
the same way. However citizens do not look up to the government, and
I’m not sure what they think of V. Citizens are probably confused if V
is a villain or a hero, because of his violent acts. The acts of
violence peaks my interest in this film, because it makes it hard to
interpret if V is a hero or not. This adds to the understanding of the
motifs in this film.
http://www.jesusradicals.com/sources-of-violence/
I really liked how you made a connection between the "savior" and the "unjust". I completely agree that even though some one may be seen as helping a cause by taking over a controlling power, by killing them, but what makes them any better than the ones committing the crimes? There is never a correct answer in this case, it seems to me. I just the only way to see what is the correct actions here is by taking a Utilitarian stand point, and see what is morally correct and what will increase happiness the most.
ReplyDelete